Did Bible scholars debate Ishmael's age when he left Abraham's house?

Yes, classical Bible scholars have indeed debated Ishmael's age when he and his mother Hagar were sent away from Abraham's household. The primary source of this debate stems from the biblical texts in Genesis.

According to Genesis 21, verses 8-14, the event occurred after Isaac was weaned. Since weaning typically happened around the age of three in ancient times, Ishmael would have been around 17 years old, given that he was 14 years older than Isaac. However, some interpretations of the text suggest that Ishmael is depicted as a much younger child, which has led to discussions about potential inconsistencies or symbolic interpretations within the narrative.

This debate highlights the complexities and nuances in interpreting ancient texts, where cultural, historical, and linguistic contexts play significant roles.

Some people think that Ishmael, when sent away by Abraham in the Torah, was just a young child, not a teenager, based on the phrase "and he grew" in Genesis 21, verse 20. They point out that the Hebrew word "yelid" is used for both Ishmael and baby Moses (Exodus 2, verse 6). How do they explain this argument?

The argument is articulated by pointing out the use of the Hebrew word "yelid" in both Genesis 21, verses 14 to 15, and Exodus 2, verse 6. In these verses, "yelid" is used to describe both Ishmael and infant Moses. Supporters of the argument claim that since "yelid" is used to describe Moses when he was an infant, it should also be understood to mean that Ishmael was still a young child in Genesis 21, verse 20.

Additionally, the phrase "and he grew" in Genesis 21, verse 20, is interpreted by some to imply that Ishmael was still in the process of growing and developing, suggesting a younger age. They argue that if Ishmael were already a teenager or older, it would not be necessary to mention his growth.

It should be noted, however, that interpretations of biblical texts can vary, and different scholars or readers may have different understandings of the intended meaning.

Here is how the Jewish scribe manipulated Ishmael's story:

1. The age of Ishmael at the time of his departure from Abraham's house.

2. Abraham's son, who was offered as a sacrifice.

Contrasting Narratives: The Story of Hagar and Ishmael in Islamic and Judeo-Christian Traditions

Genesis 21, verses 9 to 10, reads:

But Sarah saw that the son whom Hagar the Egyptian had borne to Abraham was mocking, and she said to Abraham, “Get rid of that slave woman and her son, for that woman's son will never share in the inheritance with my son Isaac.”

Certain Islamic scholars assert that the narrative concerning Hagar and Ishmael as depicted in the Torah may have undergone modifications by later scribes. They propose that the verses in Genesis 21, verses 9 to 10 may have been inserted at a later date, given that Hagar and Ishmael had already left Abraham's household prior to the birth of Isaac. Furthermore, Islamic tradition indicates that Ishmael was an infant during this period (when departing from Abraham’s household).

The story of Abraham, Hagar, and Ishmael is recounted in both Islamic and Judeo-Christian traditions, but the interpretations of events differ significantly, especially regarding motivations and circumstances.

In Islamic tradition, the narrative emphasizes that Abraham's decision to leave Hagar and Ishmael in the desert was a direct command from God. This command is viewed as a test of Abraham's faith and obedience to divine will. Muslims interpret Abraham's actions as noble and part of a larger divine plan, which highlights his trust in God's wisdom. The act is not attributed to any personal motives, such as jealousy or resentment, but is instead seen as a fulfilling of God's purpose for Abraham and his family.

Conversely, in the Judeo-Christian tradition, the focus shifts more towards human emotions and relationships. The narrative often centers around Sarah's jealousy and insecurity upon seeing Ishmael mock Isaac, her son with Abraham. This jealousy leads Sarah to demand that Abraham expel Hagar and Ishmael from their home. This viewpoint highlights how complicated human feelings can be and the possible disagreements that might occur within family relationships. These conflicts can lead to feelings of being left out due to personal emotions.

Concerning the age discrepancy, Islamic texts typically depict Ishmael as a nursing infant when Hagar was left in the desert. This portrayal aligns with the practical realities of the situation, as it is more feasible for a mother to carry a small child rather than an older one. The narrative implies that Hagar, in her role as a mother, is caring for a very young child, which makes Abraham's abandonment of them even more poignant given their vulnerability.

In contrast, the Biblical account presents Ishmael as approximately 17 years old at the time of his expulsion. This significant age difference raises questions about the practicality of the situation. If Ishmael were indeed a teenager, it would be less feasible for Hagar to carry him in the way described in the narratives. Additionally, the image of a young man depicted as helpless under a bush can create a conflicting view of his character, complicating the emotional weight of the story.

In conclusion, the Islamic viewpoint on the story of Hagar and Ishmael as presented in the Torah is marked by skepticism regarding the authenticity of certain verses. Islamic scholars argue that the timeline and events described in the Torah may have been altered, and Islamic tradition suggests that Ishmael was an infant during this period (when departing from Abraham’s household).