Why is Isaac's name linked to Sarah, while Ishmael's name is linked to God?

The names Isaac and Ishmael, and their connections to Sarah and God, respectively, are rooted in their biblical narratives found in the book of Genesis.

Isaac's Name and Connection to Sarah:

Isaac's name (Hebrew: Yitzchak) means "he will laugh" or "he laughs." The naming of Isaac is directly linked to Sarah's reaction upon hearing the news that she would bear a son in her old age. There are two significant moments where laughter is mentioned in relation to Isaac's birth:

1. In Genesis 18, verse 12, Sarah laughs to herself when she overhears the three visitors telling Abraham that she will have a son the following year. Sarah is past the age of childbearing, so the idea seems laughable to her.

2. In Genesis 21, verse 6, after Isaac is born, Sarah says, "God has brought me laughter, and everyone who hears about this will laugh with me."

Thus, Isaac's name is a reminder of the joy and surprise his birth brought, especially to his mother, Sarah. It signifies the fulfillment of God's promise to Abraham and Sarah that they would have a son, despite their advanced ages.

Ishmael's Name and Connection to God:

Ishmael's name (Hebrew: Yishma'el) means "God will hear" or "God hears." The naming of Ishmael is tied to God's response to the plight of his mother, Hagar. When Hagar is pregnant with Abraham’s child, she flees into the desert to escape mistreatment by Sarah. There, an angel of the Lord finds Hagar and speaks to her:

1. In Genesis 16, verse 11, the angel of the Lord tells Hagar, "You are now pregnant and you will give birth to a son. You shall name him Ishmael, for the Lord has heard of your misery."

Hagar is comforted by the knowledge that God has heard her affliction, which is reflected in the name given to her son. Ishmael's name thus signifies God's awareness of Hagar's suffering and His intervention on her behalf.

In summary, Isaac's name is linked to Sarah due to the joy and laughter associated with the miraculous circumstances of his birth, reflecting the fulfillment of God's promise to her. Ishmael's name is linked to God because it signifies God's compassionate response to Hagar's distress, highlighting His attentiveness to human suffering.

——-

From a Islamic perspective the etymology of the name Ishmael has been linked to the perceived divine response to Abraham's supplication as mentioned in Surah 37, verses 100 to 101. How do proponents of this view support and elucidate this argument?

Supporters of the theory connecting the name Ishmael to Abraham's prayer in Surah 37, verses 100 to 101 argue that in these verses, Abraham requests a pious son.

The verse reads:

"My Lord, grant me [a child] from among the righteous. So We gave him good tidings of a forbearing boy."

The Quran mentions that after his prayer, Abraham was blessed with Ishmael. This connection between the supplication and the birth of Ishmael is seen as evidence of divine intervention and fulfillment of Abraham's request.

Furthermore, proponents argue that the etymology of the name Ishmael itself can be interpreted as meaning "God hears" or "God listens." This interpretation aligns with the idea that Ishmael was born in response to Abraham's prayer and serves as a reminder of God's ability to hear and answer prayers.

Overall, supporters of this view believe that the story of Abraham's supplication and the birth of Ishmael exemplify divine intervention and serve as a testament to God's responsiveness to his followers' prayers.

Ishmael was the fruit of Abraham, while Isaac was a gift of God to Abraham

From the Islamic perspective, Ishmael was the fruit of Abraham, while Isaac was a gift of God to Abraham due to his willingness to sacrifice his firstborn son, Ishmael. What is the explanation for this?

In Islamic tradition, both Ishmael and Isaac are revered as prophets and are the sons of the Prophet Abraham. Here's a breakdown from the Islamic perspective:

1. Ishmael: He is the first son of Abraham and Hagar. When Hagar and her infant son Ishmael were in the desert, God provided them with the well of Zamzam. Ishmael and his father, Abraham, later constructed the Kaaba in Mecca. The majority of Islamic traditions indicate that it was Ishmael, not Isaac, whom Abraham was commanded to sacrifice. However, at the last moment, God provided a ram to sacrifice in place of Ishmael. This event is commemorated during Eid al-Adha.

2. Isaac: He is the second son of Abraham and his wife, Sarah. In Islamic narratives, after the trial of the sacrifice, as a reward for Abraham's unwavering faith, God blessed him with a second son, Isaac, through Sarah. Isaac is also considered a prophet and is respected in Islamic tradition.

The Islamic account differs from the Jewish and Christian traditions, where Isaac is the one whom Abraham is commanded to sacrifice. In the Qur'an, the specific name of the son to be sacrificed is not mentioned, but many Islamic scholars and traditions identify him as Ishmael based on the sequence of events in the Quran, which suggests that the promise of Isaac's birth came after the sacrifice narrative, implying Ishmael was the son involved (Surah 37, verses 100 to 112).


What does the Arabic word “نَافِلَةً” mean in Surah 21, verse 72, in the Quran? Could you elaborate more on why the Quran uses such a word to refer to Abraham concerning Isaac and Jacob?

The Arabic word "نَافِلَةً" in Surah 21, verse 72 of the Quran refers to "additional" or "extra" in English. In this verse, it is used to describe how Allah favored Abraham by giving him the additional gift of Isaac and Jacob, in addition to his son Ishmael.

This word is significant in this context because it highlights the special and additional blessings that Allah bestowed upon Prophet Abraham. It emphasizes the extraordinary nature of the gift of Isaac and Jacob, in addition to his first son Ishmael, as a form of divine favor and grace.

The use of the word "نَافِلَةً" also emphasizes the generosity and abundance of Allah's blessings, highlighting the multiplicity of children and the continuity of prophethood within Prophet Abraham's lineage. This choice of wording serves to underscore the extraordinary nature of Allah's favors and blessings upon his chosen prophets and their descendants.

Overall, the use of the word "نَافِلَةً" in this verse serves to emphasize the exceptional nature of the gift of Isaac and Jacob to Prophet Abraham, in addition to his son Ishmael, highlighting the abundance and generosity of Allah's blessings upon his chosen servants.

The Symbolism of Eid al-Adha (Feast of the Sacrifice)

What is Eid al-Adha?
Eid al-Adha is the “Feast of the Sacrifice,” commemorating Abraham’s devotion to God, when he intended to sacrifice his son and God provided a lamb to sacrifice instead. It follows the Hajj rituals for pilgrims in Mecca, but is celebrated by all Muslims.

Certain scholars contend that Eid Al Adha in Islam suggests a scribal interpolation in the Torah concerning the son intended for near sacrifice, positing that it is Ishmael rather than Isaac. How is their argument articulated?

Some Islamic scholars argue that Eid al-Adha in Islam points to a scribal interpolation in the Torah regarding which son Abraham was commanded to sacrifice. Their argument for scribal interpolation is articulated as follows:

Islamic tradition holds that it was Ishmael, not Isaac, whom Abraham was commanded to sacrifice. This belief forms the basis for the celebration of Eid al-Adha, one of the most important festivals in Islam.

Scholars who support this view present several arguments:
1. Primacy of Ishmael: They argue that Ishmael, being Abraham's firstborn son, was the original heir to the covenant and thus the logical choice for such a significant test of faith.

2. Quranic Account: The Quran's narrative of the sacrifice does not explicitly name the son, but contextual evidence and Islamic tradition point to Ishmael. This interpretation stems from the chronological events presented in the Quran, indicating that the promise of Isaac's birth occurred after the narrative of the sacrifice, thereby suggesting that Ishmael was the son mentioned in that context.

3. Historical Context: These scholars suggest that ancient Israelite scribes may have altered the original text to emphasize Isaac's role, shifting the focus away from Ishmael to establish a stronger theological foundation for Israelite claims.

4. Geographical Inconsistencies: They point out that the biblical account mentions Mount Moriah, while Islamic tradition places the event near Mecca, where Ishmael and Hagar settled.

5. Linguistic Analysis: Some argue that careful examination of the original Hebrew text reveals inconsistencies that suggest later editing.
If this interpretation is accepted, it would have significant implications:

It would challenge the traditional Jewish and Christian understanding of the Abrahamic covenant.
It would support the Islamic view of Ishmael as a central figure in the Abrahamic narrative.
It would reinforce the Islamic belief in the Quran as a correction to earlier scriptures.

What theological reasoning do Islamic scholars offer to explain how Abraham's near sacrifice of Ishmael, instead of Isaac, supports the prophethood of Muhammad?

According to Islamic tradition and theology, the near sacrifice of Ishmael by Abraham, rather than Isaac, provides support for the prophethood of Muhammad in several key ways:

Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all trace their spiritual lineage to Abraham as a shared patriarch. The story of Abraham's willingness to sacrifice his son at God's command is seen as a supreme test of faith in all three traditions. By identifying the son as Ishmael rather than Isaac, Islam establishes a direct link between Abraham and Muhammad through Ishmael.

The Quran in Surah 37 recounts the story of Abraham's willingness to sacrifice his son out of obedience to God. Despite not explicitly naming the son, the Quran places the narrative of the sacrifice before the announcement of Isaac's birth, which some interpret as an indication that Ishmael was the one sacrificed. This Quranic account is seen as affirming Ishmael's role.

Islamic tradition holds that Muhammad is a direct descendant of Ishmael. The legitimacy and authenticity of Muhammad's prophethood is thus connected to this lineage going back to Abraham through Ishmael. Ishmael's willingness to be sacrificed is viewed as a significant event that foreshadows the prophethood of Muhammad, which holds a central role in the religion.

Muslims believe the Quran is the final, unaltered word of God as revealed to Muhammad, arguing that earlier scriptures like the Torah and Bible have been changed over time. In this view, the Quran corrects these alterations, and its indication that Ishmael was the sacrificial son is seen as the accurate version of the story. This affirms Muhammad's role in restoring the original monotheistic message.